Qubits vs. Bureaucracy: The Untold
Story of India’s Quantum Pioneer
In the rapidly advancing realm of global quantum computing, countries are racing to attain supremacy over what is considered the next great leap in technology. While nations like the United States, China, and members of the European Union have already made massive strides in this domain, India has often lagged behind—despite its enormous potential and scientific talent pool. Now, a passionate physicist who returned from the West is spearheading India’s mission to catch up. But what should have been a story of scientific ambition is being transformed into a cautionary tale of bureaucratic red tape, systemic delays, and institutional inertia.
This is the story of Dr. Arvind
Malhotra, a quantum physicist who left a thriving academic career in the United
States to bring quantum revolution to his homeland. Yet, his biggest challenge
has not been quantum decoherence or entanglement—it has been the Indian
bureaucracy.
Quantum computing is not just
another technological development—it represents a paradigm shift. Unlike
classical computers, which process information in binary bits (0 or 1), quantum
computers use quantum bits or qubits. These can exist in multiple states
simultaneously, enabling them to process massive datasets and solve complex
problems at unprecedented speeds.
Governments across the world are
investing heavily in this technology. Quantum computing holds the key to breakthroughs
in cryptography, materials science, drug discovery, climate modeling, and
defense strategy. The United States has dedicated over $2 billion under the
National Quantum Initiative, while China is building quantum networks and
supercomputers with state sponsorship. The European Union has earmarked €1
billion for quantum research under the Quantum Flagship program.
India, realizing the strategic
importance of this field, launched the National Mission on Quantum Technologies
and Applications (NM-QTA) in 2020, with a budget of ₹8000 crore. But funding
alone cannot guarantee success—efficient execution, technical leadership, and
institutional support are essential. That’s where Dr. Malhotra’s story becomes
crucial.
A
Scientist's Homecoming
Dr. Arvind Malhotra earned his PhD
in quantum physics from Stanford University and went on to work with IBM’s
Quantum Lab and later, at MIT’s Center for Theoretical Physics. By 2021, he had
published over 40 research papers and developed pioneering techniques for
quantum gate fidelity and quantum error correction.
But a deeper calling brought him
back to India. He was driven by the idea that India should not remain a passive
observer in the global quantum revolution. “India is known for its software
prowess and mathematical talent. It was only natural that we step into quantum
technology, which blends both,” he explained in an interview.
With his vision aligned with
national objectives, Dr. Malhotra submitted a proposal to the Department of
Science and Technology under NM-QTA—to establish India’s first superconducting
quantum lab and build a functional 20-qubit quantum computer using indigenous
hardware and algorithms.
When
Innovation Meets Bureaucracy
The proposal was approved, funding
was sanctioned, and public announcements were made. But what followed was a
Kafkaesque journey through bureaucratic hurdles. Dr. Malhotra found himself
tangled in a web of regulations, approvals, audits, and procurement
formalities.
The first major obstacle was
importing cryogenic equipment from Germany. These high-tech systems, essential
for cooling quantum processors to near absolute zero, remained stuck in customs
for eight months. The reason? Confusion over tariff classification and pending
clearance from the Ministry of External Affairs.
Even worse was the situation with
hiring. Building a quantum team requires immediate recruitment of physicists,
engineers, and data scientists. But in India’s government-backed institutions,
hiring even a temporary researcher requires layers of approvals from finance,
HR, legal, and sometimes vigilance departments. While Dr. Malhotra waited
months to fill essential positions, talent drained away to international
opportunities.
Procurement
Paralysis and Paper Trails
Purchasing state-of-the-art
components like quantum amplifiers, Josephson junctions, or microwave control
systems became a nightmare. Government rules required issuing open tenders—even
when the equipment could only be sourced from a few niche global vendors.
The procurement committee—composed
of general administrators—often lacked the technical expertise to evaluate the
equipment’s necessity or urgency. In one case, a ₹40 lakh spectrometer’s
purchase was delayed for over a year simply because a committee member wanted “more
cost-effective alternatives.”
The result? Delays, cost overruns,
and missed milestones.
Fighting
with Vision and Resilience
Despite these challenges, Dr.
Malhotra remained committed. Operating from a makeshift lab within an IIT
campus, he built a team of 30 researchers. Many were young PhD scholars eager
to work on cutting-edge science in their own country. Others were
foreign-returned scientists like himself, disillusioned by the slow pace but
inspired by his vision.
The team worked long hours and
relied on innovation to circumvent bureaucratic obstacles. They built some
components in-house using 3D printers. They borrowed equipment from private
labs and even took the unconventional step of crowd-funding smaller pieces of
hardware.
These out-of-the-box strategies
allowed the team to demonstrate a 3-qubit processor in mid-2024—a remarkable
feat under the circumstances. The processor, though modest by global standards,
was entirely built in India with custom algorithms optimized for India-specific
problems like agricultural modeling and earthquake forecasting.
Systemic
Inertia: The Core of the Problem
Dr. Malhotra’s case is not an
isolated incident. Many Indian scientists across fields—AI, biotechnology,
defense tech—have echoed similar frustrations. At the heart of the problem lies
the mismatch between a 21st-century innovation ecosystem and a colonial-era
administrative framework.
Government financial rules (GFR)
treat R&D projects with the same scrutiny as civil works or procurement of
office furniture. This not only kills agility but punishes risk-taking—an
essential element of scientific progress. The lack of autonomy for project
heads, complex audit procedures, and slow inter-departmental coordination
create a perfect storm of inefficiency.
A
Need for Policy Reformation
The success of India’s quantum
mission hinges on systemic reforms, not just technical talent. Leading experts
have suggested the following steps:
1.
Create a
National Quantum Innovation Council
with executive powers to fast-track critical projects.
2.
Provide
financial and procurement autonomy
to Principal Investigators of strategic missions.
3.
Establish
an integrated clearance cell
to handle import licensing, customs, and logistics for research labs.
4.
Recruit
domain experts into administrative roles
in science ministries and funding agencies.
5.
Encourage
PPP (Public-Private Partnership)
models for building quantum infrastructure and industry applications.
Countries like Israel, South Korea,
and the Netherlands have adopted such strategies to empower their research
ecosystem. India can take cues to evolve beyond its bureaucratic bottlenecks.
Hope
Amidst Hardship
The turning point came in early 2025
when the Prime Minister's Office (PMO) took notice of delays in key quantum
projects. Following a review, a task force was formed to identify pain points
and fast-track projects of national importance. Dr. Malhotra’s lab was
shortlisted as a key national node in India’s emerging quantum network.
With intervention from higher
authorities, procurement rules were relaxed, and hiring was delegated to the
institutional level. This newfound support bore fruit. In March 2025, Dr.
Malhotra’s lab unveiled a prototype 5-qubit system—IndiQ-5—that performed basic
quantum simulations on local climate data.
It marked a historic moment. India
had officially entered the club of nations with indigenous quantum processing
capability.
The
Road Ahead: Challenges and Opportunities
India’s quantum journey is just
beginning. A 5-qubit processor is a stepping stone toward much larger, more
powerful systems. The global standard now stands at over 1000 qubits, with tech
giants like IBM, Google, and Rigetti pushing boundaries.
However, India’s strength lies in
its potential to innovate locally. Dr. Malhotra believes that Indian quantum
computers should not just replicate Western models but solve uniquely Indian
problems—rural logistics, monsoon prediction, real-time crop insurance
modeling, quantum cryptography for Aadhaar data, and more.
To do this, the ecosystem must
expand beyond one lab or one mission. Universities, startups, and industries
must collaborate. Private investment must flow. Quantum education must become
mainstream across IITs, NITs, and state universities.
Inspiring
the Next Generation
Dr. Malhotra now spends part of his
time mentoring young scientists and speaking at universities across the
country. His goal is to inspire more returnees and fresh graduates to join the
quantum cause.
He is also lobbying for India’s
first dedicated Quantum Technology Park—a campus that brings together academia,
startups, and global partners under one roof. Discussions are underway with the
Department of Science and several state governments to allocate land and
funding.
“It’s not about one person or one
lab. It’s about building an ecosystem where the next 100 quantum scientists can
thrive without battling red tape every day,” says Dr. Malhotra.
Conclusion:
A Quantum Leap Requires More Than Qubits
Building a quantum computer is one
of the hardest technological feats of our time. But in India, the challenge is
even harder—not because of a lack of talent, but because of the obstacles posed
by an outdated system. Dr. Arvind Malhotra’s story is a beacon of hope and a
call to action. It reminds us that science cannot flourish without freedom, and
innovation cannot survive without trust.
If India wants to be a quantum
power, it must empower its scientists—not only with money but with the
autonomy, agility, and institutional respect they deserve. Only then can we
truly make a quantum leap into the future.
Post a Comment